|
Scriptural Evidence for Home
Fellowships
Today more and more people are meeting in private homes each Sabbath for worship. These small groups are referred to by various names such as Home Fellowships, House Churches, and probably the most popular term, "The Living Room Church of God". These Christians are often criticized for this practice by some of the leaders and members of the religious organizations of our tradition. An example of this criticism is seen in a quote from a sermon given by a minister where he said:
This speaker is implying that a Living Room Church of God is unbiblical, that it is not a "congregation" or a "church." What does the Bible say? Is the modern practice of small groups of people meeting in private homes for worship, fellowship and instruction unbiblical? The purpose of this study is to examine scriptural evidence showing that it was a normal New Testament practice for small groups of Christians to assemble in private home for worship, fellowship and instruction. This study will not explore the subject of Church government. The speaker implies that a Living Room Church of God has no organization and leadership. This is simply not true. What is true, is most Home Fellowships do not practice the hierarchical and authoritarian form of government used by many of the Churches of our tradition. Church government is another subject altogether, and in recent years many writers have addressed this issue.
The Greek word translated "church" is ekklesia 1577 "an assembly, a (religious) congregation" Abbott-Smith Lexicon. From the Online Bible, ekklesia 1577:
A Church is not a building, or a place where Christians met. A Church is an assembly or congregation of Christians. Historical Background It is important to remember that there is no evidence: biblical, historical or archaeological of Christians having special buildings for worship during the first century.
Richard Krautheimer writing in "Early Christian and Byzantine Architecture" states:
As we examine the biblical evidence, we will see the importance of "domestic architecture," (i.e. the private home to the New Testament Church of God). Direct Evidence for Assembling in Private Houses First we will examine the direct scriptural evidence for Christians assembling in private homes. After looking at the direct evidence, we will examine the indirect evidence for home assemblies. (4) The Assembly in the Ephesian House of Aquila and Priscilla First Corinthians is written in the city of Ephesus during the spring of A.D. 57, (5) by the apostle Paul. At that time an assembly of Christians are meeting in the house of Aquila and Priscilla:
All scripture quoted are from the New American Standard Bible (NASB), unless otherwise stated). As we will see later this was probably not the only House Church in Ephesus. The Assembly in the Roman House of Priscilla and Aquila Paul's letter to the Roman Christians is written in the city of Corinth during the spring of A.D. 58. By this time Priscilla and Aquila had returned to Rome, where they had once lived (Acts18:2), and a assembly of Christians were meeting in their house:
Like Ephesus, we will see that the House Church of Priscilla and Aquila was not the only assembly of Christians in Rome. The Assembly in the House of Philemon Paul's letter to the Colossians is written from Rome some time around A.D. 61 or 62, during his first Roman captivity (A.D. 61-63). This is the period of time covered in Acts 28:16-31. The letter was apparently delivered by Tychicus and Onesimus. Onesimus was a native of Colossae (Colossians 4:7-9). He was a runaway slave of Philemon, who ending up in Rome, was converted by Paul (Philemon 15-16, 10). In addressing his letter to Philemon, written at the same time as the letter to the Colossians (A.D. 61 or 62), Paul sends greetings to the assembly of Christians meeting Philemon's house:
The Christians of Colossae assembled in Philemon's home. The Assembly in the House of Nympha In his letter to the Colossians, Paul makes reference to another House Church:
In the area of Laodicea there appears to be two groups of Christians. The first group being "the brethren who are in Laodicea," or as in verse 16 "the church of the Laodiceans." The second group is "Nympha and the church that is in her house." It is also possible that only one group of people is being referred to, and the entire Laodicean Church assembled in the house of Nympha. Small Congregations We see from these scriptures that some 30 years after the crucifixion Christian were meeting in private homes. By the very nature of meeting in homes, these congregations were not large, but small. Each assembly was only as large as the biggest room in a given home. Richard Krautheimer describes what these homes were like:
Indirect Evidence of Assembling in Private Houses The following scriptures refer to Christians assembling in private homes. These verses are not as straight forward as the scriptures we just examined, but are indirect or secondary evidence. The Practice of the Jerusalem Church The first seven chapters of Acts
are a condensed history of the early Church of God, covering the time
period of A.D. 31 to 37. Meeting in private homes is a practice that can
be traced back to the early Jerusalem Church of God.
Some time later, private homes were no longer in use just for fellowship. The apostles utilized them as another location besides the Temple to teach and preach:
Around A.D. 37, Saul led a persecution against the Jerusalem Church (Acts 8:1-3). In writing about this persecution Luke records:
Why did Paul enter "house after house"? Because he knew that is where he would find Christians gathering to be taught and to fellowship. The private house was still being used as a location for Jerusalem Christians to assemble during another period of persecution in A.D. 44. During this persecution, James the brother of John is killed by Herod Agrippa I (reigned from A.D. 41-44), and Peter is imprisoned. Herod plans to keep Peter in prison until after Passover and the Days of Unleavened Bread, then kill him (Acts12:1-5). While Peter is in prison, the Jerusalem Christians are continually praying for him (verse 5). The inference here is to communal prayer, not just individual prayer. This is supported by verse 12 where it states that people were gathered for prayer. Verse 6-11 deal with Peter being set free from prison. Realizing he was truly free, and not having a dream, Peter
One reason Peter went to the house of Mary that night, besides it being close by, may have been that he knew this was one of those houses in Jerusalem were Christians gathered to be taught and to fellowship. What is known, is that on this night people were gathered at Mary's home for prayer. This night was probably the night following the Last Day of Unleavened Bread. Remember, Herod did not want to kill Peter until after the Feast (Acts 12:4), and "on the very night when Herod was about to bring him forward" (verse 6) Peter is set free. It appears Herod was going to act as soon as possible after the Days of Unleavened Bread as he could. There is another reason for Peter going to Mary's house that night. If Mary's house was a regular meeting place for some of the Jerusalem brethren. Paul knew some of them would still be there that night having a fellowship meal, following the end of the Feast of Unleavened Bread. Peter did not stay at Mary's house. Her house may have been a known location for Christian gatherings. Plus, if it was close to where Peter was imprisoned, it would be natural for the authorities to look for Peter in Mary's house (verse 17). These scriptures in the book Acts indicate that the Jerusalem Church of God was a collection of House Assemblies or Churches. The Jerusalem Christians assembled in private houses for fellowship and instruction from the word of God. This is the same activity taking place today in the Home Fellowships or Living Room Churches of God of our tradition. Thessalonica and the "House of Jason" After departing Philippi (Acts 16:40) Paul arrives in Thessalonica. It is approximately the fall A.D. 51. He preaches in the local synagogue over a period of three Sabbaths. This results in some Jewish, and even a greater number of Gentile converts to Christianity (Acts 17:1-4). This angered a few of the Jews, who stir up a mob, made up of "wicked men from the marketplace" (verse 5). The mob attacks the "house of Jason" looking for Paul and Silas (verse 5). While in Thessalonica Paul and Silas were staying in the home of Jason (verse 7). Not finding them at the "house of Jason," the mob found "Jason and some brethren" who they took to the authorities of the city (verse 6).There is the suggestion here that the "house of Jason" was more then just the place where Paul and Silas were staying. It had become the first meeting place outside of the synagogue for the Church in Thessalonica. Verse 4 records that some of the Jews as well as "God-fearing Greeks" and "leading women" of the city, "joined Paul and Silas." This may mean they accepted the same religion as Paul and Silas, but that meaning is rather narrow when we examine the context of the verse. When the mob raided the "house of Jason" they only found "Jason and some brethren" (verses 5- 6). This would imply that joining Paul and Silas meant joining them in assembling at the "house of Jason." The loss of these people from participating in the synagogue may have been the motivating factor in the attack on Jason's house. Corinthian House Churches After leaving Thessalonica, Paul travels to Berea, Athens, then on to Corinth (Acts 17:10-18:1). He stays there for about a year and half (verse 11), early A.D. 52 to the middle of A.D.53. Paul starts out preaching in the local synagogue. The Jews of Corinth reject Paul's message. From then on, he concentrates on preaching to the Gentiles (Acts 18:1-6). Paul no longer goes to the synagogue to preach, but:
The house of Titius Justus becomes Paul's base of operation, and an early meeting place for the young Corinthian Church. The Corinthian Church starts out as a House Church, (i.e. a Living Room Church of God). By examining the scriptures we see that there are three other possible House Churches in Corinth. First Corinthians refers to two of these House Churches. Paul sends this letter from Ephesus during the spring of A.D. 57. The first possibility occurs in 1 Corinthians1:11
The verse could also be translated:
Paul writes that he received information about the Corinthian Christians, from some people who are associated with an individual by the name of Chloe. The nature of this association is not clear. They could be members of Chloe's family, household servants or possible even members of a House Church meeting in Chloe's home. A second possibility is found in 1Corinthians 1:16
The Greek word translated "household" in verse 16 is "oikos" 3624, meaning " a house, a dwelling" Abbott-Smith Lexicon. The NASB translates this word as: descendants (1), families (1), family (1), home (19), homes (1), house (78), household (14), households (1), itself (1), palaces (1). The "house of Stephanas" is a justifiable translation. Is it possible Paul is referring to a Christian assembly meeting in the house of Stephanas? The members of this House Church being baptized by Paul himself? At the close of First Corinthians Paul refers to Stephanas again:
The English word "household" is a translation of the Greek word "oikia" 3614, meaning "a house, dwelling" and is related to "oikos" 3624 Abbott-Smith Lexicon. The NASB translates this word as: home (6), house (77), household (5), households (1), houses (7). The "house of Stephanas" is a valid translation, and that is how the King James Version translated this verse:
Is it possible Paul is referring in 1Corinthians 16:15 to an congregation of Christians meeting in the house of Stephanas? A third possible Corinthian House Church is mentioned in Paul's letter to the Christians of Rome, written from Corinth in the Spring A.D. 58:
Tertius, Paul's "secretary" writes that he is staying with a person named Gaius. Gaius is not only his host, but the "host of the whole church" in Corinth. This may mean the entire Corinthian congregation meets each Sabbath in Gaius' home. Or it may mean that when the "whole church" gathers together in one meeting, it is done at the home of Gaius. With smaller regular weekly congregational meetings taking place in the homes of Justus, Chloe and Stephanas. Gaius' home may have been used for these smaller meetings as well. Ephesian House Churches Paul arrives in Ephesus in A.D. 54. He first teaches in the Jewish synagogue for three months (Acts 19:1, 8). After meeting resistance to his message by the Jews, Paul leaves the synagogue, and begins holding public meetings for two years in the school of Tyrannus (Acts 19:9-10). Paul spent a total of three years in Ephesus (Acts 20:31), A.D. 54 through 57. During his stay in Ephesus, Paul writes First Corinthians in the spring of A.D. 57. At that time there was an assembly of Christians meeting in the house of Aquila and Priscilla:
Aquila and Priscilla had been living in Ephesus since their departure from Corinth in A.D. 53 (Acts18:18-28). In the spring of A.D. 58, Paul meets the Ephesian elders at Miletus (Acts 20:17). Commenting on his stay in Ephesus, Paul said
Paul taught publicly in "school of Tyrannus" (Acts 19:9), and "from house to house" in House Churches like the one which met in the house of Aquila and Priscilla (1 Cor. 16:19). Is it possible the Ephesian Church was a collection of House Churches, or to use a modern term Living Room Churches of God? The facts point in that direction. Troas House Church On a Saturday night in Troas, during the spring of A.D. 58, the local Christians are gathered in an "upper room" to break bread (have a fellowship meal), and listen to Paul speak (Acts 20:6-12). This may have just been a continuation of a Sabbath meeting that had begun sometime in the afternoon. These verses do not say if the upper room they were meeting in, was in a private house or in a public building. We do know the upper room was on the third floor of this building (verse 9). We also know it was a practice of the early Church to meet in the houses of its members (Rom. 16:3-5; 1 Cor. 16:19; Col. 4:15; Philm. 1-2). So it is plausible that this "upper room" was located in the house of a Troas Christian. The House of Philip The Evangelist On his way to Jerusalem in A.D. 58, Paul spends a few days in Caesarea, staying in "the house of Philip the evangelist" (Acts 21:7-8). During Paul's visit, Philip's house is a meeting place for the local Christians community (Acts 21:10-15). Is it likely Philip's house was also used for regular worship? It was large enough for him to host Paul and his traveling companions (Acts 21:8). At the same time Philip's house was able to accommodate "the local residents" (Acts 21:12) or "those from that place" (New King James Version [NKJ]), who were present when the prophet Agabus prophesied what would happen to Paul if he went to Jerusalem (verse10-12). Roman House Churches During Paul's first Roman captivity (A.D.61-63), he rented a house for two years where he preached and taught (Acts28:16, 23, 29-31). It seems likely Paul's house would have become a regular meeting place for some Roman Christians. Was Paul the host of a Living Room Church of God? The evidence points in that direction. Paul's would not have been the only House Assembly in Rome, and it definitely was not the first. There may have been as many as five other House Churches in Rome, before the arrival of Paul. Mention of these assemblies are found in Paul's letter to the Romans, written in the spring of A.D. 58. It is important to remember that at this time, Rome had no public transportation. You had to walk, or have a liter carried by servants or slaves. Carts and animals were not allowed to move around in the city during the day, only at night. This was a large spread out city. It was not practical for all Roman Christians to met together for worship. Rome appears to have had at least five House Churches. 1. An Assembly or Church in the house Priscilla and Aquila. We know for a fact that there was at least one Church or Assembly meeting in the house of Priscilla and Aquila (Rom.16:3-5). By A.D. 58 they had left Ephesus, and returned to Rome. 2. "Greet those of Aristobulus." In Romans 16:10 Paul writes:
In the NASB and as well as NKJ the word "household" is not in the Greek text, but is added by the translators. Green's Literal Translation (GLT) of Romans 16:10 has:
Paul is sending greetings to Aristobulus and those who are with him. It is possible that "those of Aristobulus" refers to group of believers meeting in the house of Aristobulus.
Again in the NASB and the NKJ the word "household" is not in the Greek text, but is added by the translators at a latter time. The GLT translation reads:
Paul is sending greetings to Narcissus and those who are with him. Is it possible that "those of Narcissus" refers to another group of believers meeting in the house of, or with Narcissus? 4. "Asyncritus . . . and the brethren with them." In his letter, Paul acknowledge an additional group of Roman Christians:
There is a group of brethren associated with Asyncritus, Phlegon, Hermas, Patrobas and Hermes, This maybe another reference to a Roman House Church. 5. "Philologus and Julia. . .and all the saints who are with them." Paul sends greeting to another group of Roman Christians, who may have made up a fifth Roman House Church:
False Teachers Subverting Whole House Churches In his letter to Titus, written around 67 A.D., Paul warns:
The Greek word translated by the NASB as "families" and in the NKJ as "households" in verse 11 is "oikos" 3624, meaning " a house, a dwelling" Abbott-Smith Lexicon. The NASB translates this word as: descendants (1), families (1), family (1), home (19), homes (1), house (78), household (14), households (1), itself (1), palaces (1). The King James Version translates verse 11 as:
Green's Literal Translation of verse 11 is similar:
Paul is warning Titus about false teachers who are subverting whole houses. This may refer to families, but it may also refer to assemblies of Christians meeting in private houses. We know from other scriptures that by the late A.D. 50s and early A.D. 60s, Christians meeting in private homes is not uncommon (Rom. 16:3-5; 1Cor. 16:19; Col. 4:15; Philem. 1-2), and this practice is traced back to the early Jerusalem Church (Acts 2:46-47; 5:42; 8:1-3; 12:12). Paul sends a similar warning about false teachers to Timothy:
Paul wrote this letter about A.D. 68, during his second imprisonment in Rome. The Greek word translated by the NASB and the NKJ as "households" in verse 6 is "oikia" 3614, "a house, dwelling" Abbott-Smith Lexicon. The NASB translates this word as: home (6), house (77), household (5), households (1), houses (7). The King James Version translates verse 6 as:
Green's Literal Translation of verse 6 is similar:
Second Timothy 3:6 may be referring to false teachers entering or creeping into some one's home, and leading them astray. But in light of evidence showing that Christians met in private homes (Acts 2:46-47; 5:42; 8:1-3; 12:12; Rom. 16:3-5; 1Cor. 16:19; Col. 4:15; Philem. 1-2), Paul appears to be warning Timothy about false teachers sneaking into House Churches and leading people astray spiritually. Towards the end of the first century (95 A.D.), the apostle John writes what is know as the Second Epistle of John. In this letter, John writes that there are certain doctrinal standards a teacher should have before he is aloud to teach.
Is it possible that John is warning a House Church to be careful who they allow to enter their assembly as a teacher? Spiros Zodhiates in his introduction to Second John writes:
New Testament House Churches - Conclusion In this study we examined scriptural evidence showing that during the period of the New Testament, small groups of Christians assembled in private homes for worship, fellowship and instruction. There are at least 21 references to House Churches in the New Testament. Clearly a very common, if not the normal practice of the New Testament Church of God. A practice those in the Living Room Church of God have returned to. House Church in Caesarea: The house of Philip the evangelist (Acts21:7-12) House Church in Colosse: The house of Philemon (Philm. 1-2) House Churches in Corinth: The house of Titius Justus (Acts
18:7) House Churches in Ephesus: The house of Aquila and Priscilla
(1 Cor.16:19) House Churches in Jerusalem: Anonymous houses (Acts 2:46-47) Anonymous houses (Acts 5:42)
The house of Nympha (Col. 4:15) House Churches in Rome: The house of Aquila and Priscilla
(Rom.16:3-5) House Church in Thessalonica: The house of Jason (Acts 17:1-9) House Church in Troas: The house with an upper room (Acts20:7-12) Footnotes: (1)
Don Hooser, "Thirty-five Reasons Not to Leave United Church of God,"
August 9,1997, Waco, Texas, transcribed from a tape of the sermon. |